So far no videos or other photos have appeared on the net showing either the launch or the smoke. It means we have to try to trace back the origin and the authenticity of this photo.
Personally I received the photo through @rrubanov:
След от пуска ракеты. На горизонте канатная дорога между Лутугина и Цоф Торез граница Снежное. pic.twitter.com/gQF3I2x13V
— Рубанов Роман (@rrubanov) July 17, 2014
The timestamp of his tweet is 18:25 July 17th. The crash was reported to be around 17:00, so there is one and a half hour in between. But at that time nobody knew it was a civilian airplane.
At 18:14 still official reports came in that a Ukrainian AN-26 had been shot down:
So when at 18:25, 11 minutes later, somebody tweets a photo of the trail of the missile, it is impossible to have photoshopped something credible with the intention to hide the truth and 'blame the Russians'.
I contacted @rrubanov and he said he recieved the tweet from @WowihaY. here it is:
Now the funny thing is that @Wowiha made a very similar calculation as I did. In the middle of the night at 1:27 he has already been tweeting about it!!!
This is (within the margin of error) exactly the same as what I calculated independently from him. And he does this within 6 hours.
The next day at 19:08 he tweets to have found a 3rd witness and indicates the area with an upside down Google Earth screenshot:
Translation of the text is:
I asked him if he had the original photo with the EXIF info. He does. It has already been released to the Ukrainian Security Service. It can not be made public (now) because it will reveal who the author is and we don't want to get this person killed.
So I asked him the next question:
16:25 local time is 13:25 UTC, since in Ukraine the time is 3 hours ahead of UTC.
UPDATE:
Some journos who are on location in East-Ukraine made a reconstruction of events on July 17th as they have seen it and been able to figure it out from eye-witnesses. This is, as you can understand, completely independent from what I'm doing here based on information from social media. You can find their report here. Everything they write is in sync with what I write about here. This is the time they report:
It fits...
Conclusion: this photo is genuine.
Also see: (pro)Russian conversations recorded from Zello just after missile launch
Also see the entire route that the BUK traveled into Ukraine
Also see: how the Russians took down MH17
Also see: satellite images reveal how the BUK has been driving near the launch location
Help spread the message, retweet:
At 18:14 still official reports came in that a Ukrainian AN-26 had been shot down:
So when at 18:25, 11 minutes later, somebody tweets a photo of the trail of the missile, it is impossible to have photoshopped something credible with the intention to hide the truth and 'blame the Russians'.
I contacted @rrubanov and he said he recieved the tweet from @WowihaY. here it is:
свидетель скинул фотку момента пуска ракеты.На горизонте канатная дорога между Лутугина и Цоф #Торез граница #Снежное pic.twitter.com/Z3mBtLjWfa
— Хуевый Торез (@WowihaY) July 17, 2014
Timestamp 18:23, 2 minutes earlier. He says he got the photo from a witness.Now the funny thing is that @Wowiha made a very similar calculation as I did. In the middle of the night at 1:27 he has already been tweeting about it!!!
нашли 2свид залпа.линии-направления набл-ния.Север вверху.Балка пос.Ремовка рядом хут.Берегись http://t.co/KKVTEvSMgF pic.twitter.com/EdddRkG11k
— Хуевый Торез (@WowihaY) July 17, 2014
He says that he found a second witness and so he is drawing the lines of sight on a map. He gets an approximate launch location.This is (within the margin of error) exactly the same as what I calculated independently from him. And he does this within 6 hours.
The next day at 19:08 he tweets to have found a 3rd witness and indicates the area with an upside down Google Earth screenshot:
#MH17 #БУК показания 3 свидетеля подтверждают пуск ракеты.север внизу pic.twitter.com/xkAmMJoyRK
— Хуевый Торез (@WowihaY) July 18, 2014
Translation of the text is:
Launch was made from this area! We weren't wrong. Third person confirm.So bear in mind that this local guy from Torez tweeted within a timeframe of 6 to 27 hours after the crash about information of three witnesses from whom one of them he received a photo. Based on that information he had already indicated from what area the missile had been launched. And it is in sync with how I calculated the area.
Said from field across Сlay Aggregate (rrubanov — maybe some facility or quarry produce clay aggregate)
Btw, there is line of rabit holes (rrubanov -- defence fighting position) there.
One more person can show exact, but ...
I asked him if he had the original photo with the EXIF info. He does. It has already been released to the Ukrainian Security Service. It can not be made public (now) because it will reveal who the author is and we don't want to get this person killed.
So I asked him the next question:
16:25 local time is 13:25 UTC, since in Ukraine the time is 3 hours ahead of UTC.
UPDATE:
Some journos who are on location in East-Ukraine made a reconstruction of events on July 17th as they have seen it and been able to figure it out from eye-witnesses. This is, as you can understand, completely independent from what I'm doing here based on information from social media. You can find their report here. Everything they write is in sync with what I write about here. This is the time they report:
It fits...
Conclusion: this photo is genuine.
Also see: (pro)Russian conversations recorded from Zello just after missile launch
Also see the entire route that the BUK traveled into Ukraine
Also see: how the Russians took down MH17
Also see: satellite images reveal how the BUK has been driving near the launch location
Also see: launch location detected of missile that shot down MH17
Also see: EXACT launch location pinpointed of MH17 missile
Also see: quick update on the military situation in East-UkraineAlso see: EXACT launch location pinpointed of MH17 missile
Also see: transport of the BUK out of Ukraine
Help spread the message, retweet:
EXIF data timestamp in #MH17 missile launch photo is 16:25:48 17th July http://t.co/Rgcg0dcBDY pic.twitter.com/n1mRCa0lvb
— djp3tros (@djp3tros) July 25, 2014
No comments:
Post a Comment